Now that was a fantastic weekend away from home. I think a few of us travelled more in hope than expectation, particularly given that the destination hadn’t always been a happy hunting ground, and the opposition did look particularly strong. And sure, there were a few shaky moments at times. But for it to go 3-0 the way it did? Terrific. It was certainly one of my favourite ever away days, and…hang on, I get the impression there may be some crossed wires.
I’ll freely admit that Plymouth Argyle were a secondary thought for me over the weekend. As I alluded to in the preview last week, I had already booked a trip abroad, which I think I can justify given that it looked certain Argyle’s game wouldn’t go ahead as scheduled.
England’s win over Spain, which I did get to see, brought significant joy. Alas, Argyle’s defeat against Sheffield Wednesday at Hillsborough offered little in the way of positivity. Apart from my Tipple performance, perhaps. If you told me before the weekend I’d end up second, that’d be a disappointment, but it’s much nicer when we’re talking about the global rankings.
Anyway, enough humble brags. There is something far more important on the horizon, with Argyle once again in “needing a reaction” territory. The next opportunity they’ll have is on Saturday, with Peterborough United the latest visitors to Home Park.
Posh are the latest EFL club to undergo some name lengthening, with their official title now “Robbie Savage’s Peterborough United” ever since the hirsute former midfielder’s arrival as head coach last month. Savage got off to the perfect start with victory away at Leicester City, but it’s no win in seven since, including defeats in all four competitions. What can we expect from his team this weekend?
Style of play
Peterborough generally like to keep the ball. They rank in the league’s top six across a variety of passing statistics, with only 14% of their passes going long (Argyle play a long ball 21% of the time), and just four League One sides have a higher average possession than Peterborough’s 55.9%.
Admittedly, that average possession is weighted by the fact they started the season with Luke Williams in charge, who bases his entire philosophy on keeping the ball. Nonetheless, this was a squad built with that in mind, and Peterborough’s average possession has still been above par, at 53%, in the five league games since Savage’s arrival.
Despite the change in the dugout, 4-2-3-1 has been the formation of choice for Peterborough throughout the campaign. And given the emphasis on keeping the ball, let’s start with the midfield who will be crucial to that objective. In four of Savage’s five league games, Liam Kelly (not the Leyton Orient ball boy pusher) and Harry Ashfield have formed the midfield double pivot. In the other, Brandon Khela was in from the start in place of Ashfield.
It’s exactly the same story in the number 10 role, where one player (Ethan Williams) has started four of Savage’s five league games, with another (Vernon Masara) starting once. Masara has occasionally been used out wide too, with Owura Edwards and academy graduate Bolu Shofowoke providing further options. Up front, we’ll surely see Harry Leonard. He’s a former Argyle transfer target if you believe the rumours, and has started every league game this season under both Peterborough managers.
All of the attacking players, and indeed several of the midfielders, will be encouraged to shoot when given the opportunity. 40% of the shots Peterborough have taken this season have been from outside the box, the fourth-highest proportion in the league. Given Argyle rank fifth in that particular metric, we should perhaps expect to see shots from all sorts of angles and distances this weekend.

In defence, the full backs – Carl Johnston on the right and Harley Mills on the left – probably pick themselves at this stage. Alex Bass has also been ever-present in goal. There are, however, decisions to be made at centre back. Any two of Lucca Mendonca, Thomas O’Connor, Sam Hughes and Josh Feeney could be given the nod to start at Home Park.
I wouldn’t describe Peterborough’s defensive approach as front-footed. They certainly don’t strike me as one of the more “in your face” pressing teams Argyle will face this season. Stockport County are the only League One team to have committed fewer fouls than Peterborough’s 128, while only Wycombe Wanderers have picked up fewer bookings.
Could it be argued that they’ve been too nice?
That can, of course, be viewed in two ways. On the one hand, Peterborough keep their discipline well, and as a result they’ll avoid giving away cheap free kicks, whilst also benefitting from fewer players missing games through suspension. On the other, could it be argued that they’ve been too nice? Have they dropped points this season (they do, after all, sit 22nd) because they’re not as well-versed in the dark arts as other teams in this league?
Given Savage’s reputation, that’d perhaps go a long way to explaining the rationale behind hiring him in the first place.
Strengths
For a team languishing in the relegation zone, Peterborough’s underlying data actually isn’t quite as bad as many may expect.
They seem to at least have a passable ability to create chances. Their xG total this season is 19.55, which is enough to rank them 12th in the league. If we only consider non-penalty xG, they move up one place further to 11th. And it’s the same story at the other end. Their total xG against (20.04) is also just about in the better half of the league table.
None of those numbers are groundbreaking. Nobody is going to be terrified of playing Peterborough after seeing their “slightly above mid-table” xG numbers. However, it is enough to construct an argument that they’re in something of a false position in the relegation zone, and they shouldn’t be taken lightly based on being 22nd alone.
Given Argyle have League One’s fourth-lowest ground duel success rate, could that prove to be a key differential this weekend?
Savage’s side use ground duels well to get themselves a foothold in games. Only five teams in the league have won more ground duels in total than Peterborough, a figure that reduces to four on a per game basis, whilst their success rate in those duels of 52.6% is enough to rank third in the league. Given Argyle have League One’s fourth-lowest ground duel success rate, could that prove to be a key differential this weekend?

Dribbling plays a role in ground duels, and there are several players in Peterborough’s ranks who are keen to run with the ball at any given opportunity. Shofowoke and Edwards stand out. The former has attempted 35 dribbles in the league this season, with the latter attempting 33. Both rank within the league’s top 15 in that regard, with Edwards in particular having a strong dribble success rate.
I’d be lying if I said that didn’t leave me particularly worried. Argyle, as we know, are in the midst of a slight defensive injury crisis. There will inevitably be players starting who aren’t at their best when dealing with opponents who run with the ball. It wouldn’t surprise me if some of the players Tom Cleverley is forced to select struggle with pace from the flanks, which will surely play into the visitors’ hands.
On a more general point, I’m impressed by Peterborough’s ability to fight to the end in games. They’ve already won four points through goals in second-half stoppage time this season, with result-altering goals scored beyond the 90th minute in home games against Mansfield Town and Burton Albion, as well as on a recent trip to Bromley. Argyle must therefore continue to push if they find themselves ahead, and not fall into the trap of dropping deep to defend a lead.
Weighted for minutes played, the average age of Peterborough’s team this season is 22.74 years. Only Barnsley (22.48) line up with a younger team.
The above may be the result of having a particularly young squad, with plenty of energy and players willing to fight for the cause. Weighted for minutes played, the average age of Peterborough’s team this season is 22.74 years. Only Barnsley (22.48) line up with a younger team. It’s no wonder that no team has scored more stoppage time goals than Peterborough, while they also consistently rank well for their number of sprints and distance covered.
When a team is performing poorly, it can be easy to assume the players are lazy or don’t care. I don’t believe that’s the case at all with Peterborough. Things may not have gone their way this season, but that hasn’t been for the lack of desire, and Argyle will need to be up for the challenge.
Weaknesses
Well, some of these are going to be easier than others. Put simply, Peterborough don’t score many goals, but concede plenty.
Posh are averaging 0.85 goals per game in the league this season – only Bradford City and AFC Wimbledon have been scoring at a slower rate. Conversely, Peterborough have conceded an average of 1.77 goals per game, with only three League One sides having a leakier defence. Furthermore, they’ve failed to score on six separate occasions in the league this season, but only kept one clean sheet in a 0-0 draw at home to Stevenage.
Game state stats don’t make for pleasant reading. No team in the league has spent less time in the lead than Peterborough, and no team has spent longer trailing. Basically, if you can’t get yourselves into the lead against this team, you’re doing something badly wrong.

Both the attack and defence are culpable to some degree, but I definitely think the strikers have been performing the worst of anyone. Peterborough have scored 11 goals from their 19.55 xG, with their underperformance of 8.55 goals the largest of any League One team. Additionally, Peterborough’s shot accuracy of 24% and shot conversion of 5% are both the lowest figures in the division.
And I think I’d have to pinpoint Leonard as the most culpable of all. He’s clearly a talented footballer, and on balance I’d have been pleased if Argyle had sign him when they had the chance. However, he’s been far too wasteful this season. Will Evans is often maligned (sometimes reasonably) for his profligacy in front of goal, but Leonard has spurned far more opportunities than Argyle’s number nine this season.

The law of averages may suggest this’ll level out eventually (though that is a fallacy in its own right). Indeed, given enough chances, Leonard may well make a decisive difference at Home Park. Nonetheless, the numbers are damning. On an xG basis, he should be the fourth-highest scorer in the league this season. As things stand, 25 League One players have scored more than Leonard.
That’s not to say the defence escape without blame either. In general, Posh have been something of a soft touch at the back, getting dribbled past on a regular basis and not making enough defensive actions to make up for that deficiency.
Overall, Peterborough have made 719 defensive actions (made up of clearances, blocks, interceptions and tackles) in the league this season. Only three teams have made fewer. Aston Villa loanee Feeney has made more than any Peterborough player, but still sits behind 48 other players across the league as a whole. That’d be understandable if Savage’s men didn’t have much defending to do but, with the league table as it is, that clearly isn’t the case.
So, my message to Cleverley? Take the handbrake off! And press!
Argyle should clearly look to take advantage of those struggles. A strong, attacking lineup could be enough to put the Peterborough defence under more pressure than they can handle. So, my message to Cleverley? Take the handbrake off! And press! No team in the league has made more errors leading to goals than Peterborough; they can certainly be pressed into mistakes.
Finally, a quick note on duels. As I mentioned earlier, Peterborough post good numbers for ground duels, but they aren’t quite as good in the air. In fact, only Notts County have a worse aerial duel success rate this season than Posh’s 43%.
Ronan Curtis should probably have ben sent off early against Wednesday, and therefore should be suspended for this one. As, by some miracle, he isn’t, I’d be keen to start him and trust that his aerial ability could take Argyle a long way.
Prediction
Despite their poor form, Argyle would do well not to underestimate their opponents. Peterborough’s numbers aren’t as bad as their league position would suggest, and I suspect they’ll create their fair share of chances this weekend.
That said, I do still have the Greens down as the more likely winners, perhaps with the assistance of a late goal to make the scoreline look more comfortable than the game itself warrants.
Plymouth Argyle 3-1 Peterborough United
We are proud to be working with Children’s Hospice South West (CHSW) as Argyle Life’s Official Charity Partner for the 2026/27 season. You can learn more about CHSW’s work by clicking here, and supporters who would like to make a contribution can do so via our JustGiving page.